I have tried four different flavors: Banana, Peach, Cherry, and Fig. I have tried them individually, mixed all together, paired, etc. I have found that the banana is least liked by my phelsuma(don't know why). The best combination I have found was one that Julie Bergman mentioned to me and has since been referred to as "Phelsuma Crack" is the fig with cherry mixture. The scent on these two is so strong, it is almost cloying when you open the pouches. I usually mix in honey and yogurt(flavor depends on what is in the fridge at the time). When I mix, I tend to put more flavor than directed, but that is just what has worked for me to get my animals to consume this before it dries up. I personally don't think you could go wrong with any of the flavors, though.