Tokays and CITES?

NicKtheGreeK1997

New member
That should be done with ALL species. Even if they are not rare it's ridiculous to buy WC animals when there are tame and learnt in captivity CB animals.Any people who supports exporting and/or catches WC animals should be ashamed. I will never put a wild animal in a cage, no matter what CITES it is.
 

tombo46

New member
That should be done with ALL species. Even if they are not rare it's ridiculous to buy WC animals when there are tame and learnt in captivity CB animals.Any people who supports exporting and/or catches WC animals should be ashamed. I will never put a wild animal in a cage, no matter what CITES it is.

I agree with you to a certain degree however there is still a need for WC animals. At present there are so many LTC Tokay around there will be a lot of "new blood" availiable to incorporate into breeding projects for years to come. What happens years down the line though? Do Tokays end up with the same problems as leopard geckos due to mass inbreeding?

I do agree that at present there is no need for WC Tokays though. At least not normals. The only WC Tokay I would buy is a nice morph. Reason being is that most of the morphs come from food farms. I'd rather it be in an enclosure in England than on someone's plate in Indonesia. Also by starting captive breeding projects with these morphs and by making them availiable to people as more "desirable" Tokays (due to their rarity) we can cut the need for WC imports and concentrate on CB Tokays.
 

Graham_s

Super Moderator
I am not surprised that they are considering Tokays for CITES. Once the Far East decides that they have found a cure for something, they essentially doom the species to extinction. I am surprised that Tigers have lasted so long with all the baloney about their medical properties...


I have never liked the idea of WC animals, and I still don't "agree" with it as such... but like you say, if you are operating a large-scale breeding programme, then I think it is useful to have access to WC animals.

However, I think it would be best if only the established, successful breeders had that access.

If it benefits the species by ultimately producing a reasonable number of offspring, then, IMO, the end justifies the means.
If WC animals are acquired just to give someone to look at or as a pet, that is when I think it is plain wrong.

Having learned a lot about CITES and how they work, I don't think it would be impossible to make it so that permits or licences had to be issued in order to acquire WC animals. But to be honest, I haven't really thought it through, so maybe not.
 

billewicz

New member
I agree with you to a certain degree however there is still a need for WC animals. At present there are so many LTC Tokay around there will be a lot of "new blood" availiable to incorporate into breeding projects for years to come. What happens years down the line though? Do Tokays end up with the same problems as leopard geckos due to mass inbreeding?

I do agree that at present there is no need for WC Tokays though. At least not normals. The only WC Tokay I would buy is a nice morph. Reason being is that most of the morphs come from food farms. I'd rather it be in an enclosure in England than on someone's plate in Indonesia. Also by starting captive breeding projects with these morphs and by making them availiable to people as more "desirable" Tokays (due to their rarity) we can cut the need for WC imports and concentrate on CB Tokays.

Yes, we believe CITI's regulations or flat out closure from Indonesia is coming for Tokay.

I'm not sure I agree with "At present there are so many LTC Tokay around." Compared to what? There are less than 5 breeders here in the US with any kind of genetic diversity and breeding success at all. I have observed that most of the LTC's in collections are male because the WC female that were originally purchased together with the male died from over production of eggs.

If you need more proof, just look around. How many Malaysian Tokay do you see in breeding programs today. I know of one breeder here in the US with Malaysian stock. This Tokay was imported by the thousands for years but never established in domestic breeding programs because there's no money in it when competing with a $5 import. Now they are gone.:( I don't even see them in zoos!

I am working to acquire as many morph Tokay as I can from the food processing plant connection we have in Indonesia. Unfortunately the last group of better Tokay were 'hijacked' to China. It is cut throat.:fight:

Our goal is to put as many of these great animals in breeders hands as we can so they do not disappear. And there are Tokay coming in with each group that I've never seen before.

CITI's will set limits on exports and cause the cost of these animals to go up. This will help end the 500 lot sacks of cheap pet shop Tokay. This increase in costs will eventually give would-be breeders a small margin of income that might make it worth it for them to commit. Tokay breeding is by no means for the money right now, HA!!!!:roll:

CITI's may postpone the complete closure of Indo to Tokay export. This will give us a bit more time to establish breeding colonies. Something that takes years of work, lots of money and a true love of the animal.

I can appreciate someone saying they would never buy a WC animal. And I'm assuming that would be for display or as a pet. But to place shame on those who dedicate their incredible amounts of time and money into establishing domestically bred animals from wild caught stock, so that you can by a CB pet seems a bit unwarranted.:-x

Michael's Tokay Hoard: www.billewicz.com
 

Marauderhex

New member
I agree with what Nick said, but only to a point. You need a small stream of WC individuals coming into the captive population for genetic diversity. Failure to have this will result in a similar situation to what zoos face with cheetahs, where all the individuals are related (even if only distantly). This small stream of WC should go only to established breeders, though. I hate going to shows and seeing these WC tokays that already have 3 feet in the grave being sold for $15-25.
 

Ozymandias

New member
just a question because well i'm ignorant on the subject but would this also affect the wild population down in Florida?
 

Ozymandias

New member
so that mean cities applies to just taking animals out of the wild? sorry was under the impression that it just restricted exportation.
 

billewicz

New member
just a question because well i'm ignorant on the subject but would this also affect the wild population down in Florida?

CITES is an international agreement between regions of the world to regulate and sustain indigenous plants and animals. This primarily controls export from their place of origin.

In the case of Florida, Tokay are considered an invasive species and will not enjoy protection from harvesting. Only Alligators, Turtles and the like have CITES protection under reptiles in Florida.
 

billewicz

New member
so that mean cities applies to just taking animals out of the wild? sorry was under the impression that it just restricted exportation.

From their place of origin. So, if Tokay are listed by one of the CITES Appendices, then most Pacific rim countries like Indonesia, Vietnam, Malaysia, India and anywhere else Tokay are indigenous, the export from that country will be restricted.

Now depending on which appendices, 'farmed' Tokay may be allow to be exported while wild caught would not. The farce with farmed a lot of times is, they just put up huge net like fence in the forest to section it off and call that their 'farm' and harvest the reptile from within. Then they move the 'farm' to a new location.

But non of this has anything to do with wild Tokay in Florida. As long as they are considered invasive, they will enjoy no protection there.
 

billewicz

New member
Just to add to the documentation. This comes from a 2004 CITES publication;

"... the legal mandate of CITES does not extend to invasive alien species. CITES does not provide a mechanism for controlling international trade in invasive species and it is not possible to add species to the CITES Appendices on the basis of their invasive characteristics."

So, Tokay in Florida, Texas, Belize and Hawaii are all invasive and considered fair game.
 
Top