Do you add any supplements to your fruit mush?
I have tried to, many times. It seems geckos don't like the supplement/fruit mash mix, they prefer fruit alone.
Not sure what you mean by "dogma" (I'm a huge fan of the movie "Dogma" but this has nothing to do with our conversation :biggrin: ). I certainly question some theories and points of views. Anyway, not everyone has the same methods with a given species of captive geckos. What works for your own animals on the long term is part of my philosophy

F.e. advised tank sizes for many species are certainly well beyond the real territory surface/volume used by these species in the wild. Most do not take into account parameters such as how active is the species you want to use, how and where exactly they live in the wild. Geckos spending 95% of time in burrows or rock crevices don't need much space, and when you say you keep such 5" long species in 1' cubic enclosures, people often think it is far too small. Theory is needed, just to avoid so-called "ultimate truths" found on the Internet on more or less reliable websites. F.e. I knew someone who thought keeping 1:6 crested geckos together was fine, in a 4'x2'x4' enclosure. Even in that supposedly large room, some of the 6 females gradually stopped eating because they were bullied by more dominant females and would not lay any eggs, while keeping them in smaller groups (I would not go beyond 1:3) and in far smaller tanks give much better results.
Back to our nutritional discussion, you can add a small dish with powdered calcium to your enclosure. It cannot harm, and I have already seen some cresteds using such dishes. Not saying they all do that, but if they use it, it is purely instinct-related: just like leopard geckos try to get from sand the calcium they are needing when kept under improper conditions, if cresteds need calcium, they will find it and use it.
Just as a reminder, from Seipp & Henkel "Rhacodactylus: Biology, Husbandry... " (2000) probably the best book written on this genus, studies in the wild have learned us a lot about cresteds diet in the wild and feeding habits:
-sit-and-wait predators
-pollen eaten in subsequent quantity when in season
-opportunistic predators: smaller lizards, including young specimens of their own species, are readily eaten, young skinks of the
Austrocaledoniscincus genus, and youngs of the smaller genuses (
Bavayia...). They do eat baby rodents too.
-a wide variety of invertebrates was found in their stomachs, including spiders, orthoptera, caterpillars...
-prey insects are far less readily available in the New Caledonian patches of primary forests than in other tropical forests such as the Papuan New Guinean or Amazonian one. Thus, cresteds literally eat what is available and what is moving preferrably to non-moving food.
Now in captivity, many will tell you f.e. baby mice are not recommended since they may cause gout. True. But, again, it is all a matter of finding the right balance.
Many breeders on this side of the ocean (and in the US too) have noticed that cresteds only fed on CGD are smaller and weigh less than counterparts of the same age fed on insects with proper supplements and fruit. This has been noticed on a large scale with a significant sample of animals. How can one turn opportunistic predators which have a very broad nutritional spectrum into geckos which are fed just one same type of food, that is the question...without mentioning the impact of the very small genetic pool on their correct assimilation of such or such nutrient or micro-nutrient. Genetic issues are hard to prove on a given individual (unless keepers pay for DNA comparative analyses, which I doubt). Yet they are necessarily a big part of the problem with crested geckos when you think permits issued by New Caledonian wildlife services are for less than 200 specimens, all these permits having been delivered to scientists for study purposes and none for the gecko business, on the 1993-2006 period. All the captive cresteds are ancestors of that small population, in addition to the genetic selection to obtain such or such traits in offsprings.
Add to this that cresteds are not particularly agile hunters (I have seen many missing their prey quite often, this never happens with faster arboreal species or even with leaf-tail geckos), you will have a clear overview of the problem

They do react to prey movement but are just somehow clumsy compared to other species- roaches for example may be too fast for them, depending on the roach species you use. Or, you have to sadistically smash these roaches a little, just enough to keep them alive and reduce their mobility :evil: